In this clip we see the differences between the upper class and the lower class. We watched the clip from the pilot episode. The first section was of all the downstairs people, the servants and cooks etc and then the second is of all those upstairs, the lords and ladies of the house. This is similar to Upstairs Downstairs that preceded it by several decades. This is part of a T.V. drama for light entertainment purposes. It is a period drama. The entire show has a traditional style. This first episode is set in 1912, around the time that the Titanic sank.
Section 1 -
This clip was taken from 32 seconds in to 1 minute 32 seconds. The clip of those downstairs has a quite a serious tone, they all have their set jobs to do and a set time to them in. They know they are at the upper classes beck and call and so do not want to step out of line. The character of Mr. Carson, played by Jim Carter, is evidently the leader of those downstairs, he is the supervisor. This is shown by the fact that he sits at the head of the servants table., plus the fact that when there is a problem they report it to him. When William (Thomas Howes) is ironing the newspapers Mr Carson gives specific instructions, "Do the Times first, he only reads that at breakfast, and the Sketch for her Ladyship", this shows that even with something as minor as the Newspaper the servants are told what to do and how to do it. Another thing that shows the servants are a lower class to the house owners is their accents. The people upstairs speak the Queen's English were as most of the secants have common northern accents, except the butlers because they come into contact with the house owners on a regular basis and therefor need to be of a slightly better standing. At the very beginning of the scene, when the bells start going off, they all start with their assigned jobs. They sort of work as a team, helping each other, but there are one of the people who don't seem to be team players. The outfits worn by the servants are all very plain. The maids are dressed in black dresses, ankle length, something that is in line with the period it is set. The men, specifically the butlers, are in smart blazers, white dress shirts and cravats. This is because they are in contact with those upstairs. They all speak to each other quite informally even though they are in a work environment. They seem to be friendly to one another. The downstairs area seem to be very small with not much manoeuvring room. Even though these people are below the Lords and Ladies there is a hierarchy of the downstairs area. When the papers are delivered it is clear that even William is above the paper boy. Daisy (Sophie McShera), the assistant cook, asks a question and is immediately shot down by the cook, Mrs Patmore (Lesley Nicol), and then labelled "silly" by the maid O'Brien (Siobhan Finneran) There is a clear feeling that the servants should simply stick to what they are good at, serving. And that is indeed how life was for the lower classes in the early 1900's. The show's writers have done a very good job of portraying this.
Section 2 -
This clip was from 2:09 onwards. The next small section was to do with the people upstairs. The Lords and Ladies. They will have known the people on the Titanic because of their social class, the Titanic mainly had a lot of Upper Class people on it, they said that they had dined with some of the passengers. In the early 1900's this social distinction was very evident. The servants had their place and they were to stay there. The character of Lord Grantham (Hugh Bonneville) was very reserved and kept a stiff upper lip when he got the telegram announcing the possible death of the heirs to the estate. The scene is acted very well by Bonneville. He really shows how someone of Lord Grantham's stature would have actually reacted in such a situation. They are also all very formal, even at breakfast. They all speak formally. Another indication of the difference in classes is that when Lord Grantham arrives down for breakfast, with his dog, he is greeted as "M'Lord" whereas he simply refers to his butler as "Carson". Lady Grantham, whom we see in bed also keeps a stiff upper lip when she finds out about the passenger's possible death. The breakfast segment is one that you can take a lot from. The fact that even at breakfast they are all very formal shows us that they are of a high class. This fits in well with the serious tone of the scene. Their dress also says a lot about how they are. The Ladies of the house all come down with their hair neatly done in pristine dresses and all talk with higher class accents. Also, when Sybil (Jessica Brown-Findlay) receives the telegram from one of the butlers she takes it to Lord Grantham instead of opening it herself, this shows that Lord Grantham is the head of the household, that is how it was in the early 1900's. The men were more important than the women. That was society's view on things. When he first comes down for breakfast Lord Grantham shows that he actually did care about the lower classes and realises that there is a large gap between the upper and lower classes. When Carson says that most of the Ladies got off he replies with "You mean the Ladies in first class,". He recognises that the officials will have wanted to get the upper classes off first. Then when he is reading the telegram the girls look to him, as if waiting for him to announce what it was to them. When we first meet Lady Grantham she is in bed, being waited on by O'Brien. When she is given her tray of breakfast she says "Thank you O'Brien that will be all for the moment" she has the power to be able to order them around and have them at her beck and call. This is a very true representation of what the early 1900's were like.
Comparison
These two scenes are starkly different. I will start with the dialects. In the first section, the servants, they all have rather common accents, they do not have upper class accents. they have northern accents and therefore pronounce some words slightly differently. In contrast to this the upstairs people have upper class accents and speak the Queen's English. This is one difference between the two sections. Then there is the dress in each section. In the first section they are all dressed smartly but not in anything too elaborate, they are simply dressed in butler's outfits and maids uniforms. Except the cooks who have aprons and hats. Those upstairs on the other hand are in smart dresses and suits, this shows that they, even when they are at home, need to look presentable. This is another big difference between the upstairs and downstairs contingents. So, there are many differences between the people upstairs and the "poor devils below decks". But this is a fairly accurate depiction of what life would have been like in a country house in the early 1900's.
This period show's narrative was good. It swapped between several different scenes but did so well, it didn't seem rushed or forced, everything had a sufficient amount of time to develop their piece of script and it was visually quite good. The acting is good, the scripting is good and the camera work is good. It introduced the characters quite well, even in the short time it had we were given the names and roles of several characters. They had to fit a lot of this into the first few minutes because there was such a large cast to introduce. Overall the whole scene was very weel worked. I am a fan.
No comments:
Post a Comment